Exploring the Effectiveness of Talk Therapy: A Critical Viewpoint
Written on
Chapter 1: The Shift from Corporate to Healing
Approximately nine years ago, following the birth of our first child, my wife made the choice to step away from her corporate career.
Having battled with alopecia for years—losing not only patches of hair but also her eyebrows—she faced significant emotional distress, especially as a woman in today's society. This led her to pursue a new path in cosmetic tattooing, or microblading. This marked a pivotal moment for her as she sought a more fulfilling and balanced life.
About a year later, as I launched my natural health practice, I quickly noticed a concerning trend: a high number of individuals were struggling with their mental and emotional well-being. When I shared these observations with my wife, it ignited a deeper discussion.
Although we maintained confidentiality and didn't disclose any client specifics, we both estimated that around 90% of those we worked with were on long-term antidepressant medication. Some were taking these drugs—often prescribed for only short-term use—for decades.
It was alarming to see that the warning label on these medications, stating "NOT TO BE TAKEN FOR MORE THAN 12 WEEKS," failed to raise any red flags for many users, despite the lack of noticeable benefits.
Moreover, my wife noted that over half of her clients were also engaged in ongoing therapy, often for a minimum of three years.
At that time, the only solace I found was in the success stories of my coaching clients, who often transitioned away from medication in favor of natural methods, experiencing significant improvements in their lives.
This observation was just the beginning. As our coaching practice, Heal, expanded over the next eight years, we continued to witness this troubling trend.
The majority of our clients now approach us having been on SSRIs or pain medications for many years, often with no end in sight. Many were still in therapy, yet their challenges remained as prominent as ever.
When we ask them about their therapy experiences—what they appreciate and how it assists them—most mention that initial benefits often fade, leading them to continue attending sessions either because their doctors advised it or they felt obligated.
Upon further reflection, a consistent theme emerges: despite any initial progress that might help them confront their issues, many feel trapped in a cycle of repeatedly discussing their unhappiness without any clear path forward.
This, I believe, highlights a significant flaw in conventional talk therapy.
Overcoming Barriers to Accessing Behavioral Health Support
In this video, we explore the challenges individuals face when seeking behavioral health support and how to navigate these barriers effectively.
Section 1.1: The Need for Change in Therapy
I want to clarify that my observations are not a critique of therapists. Talk therapy can indeed be beneficial, and for many, it is essential for processing their struggles. However, I strongly believe that the approach must evolve, and I aim to explain why.
Through our extensive experience with thousands of clients, a recurring issue is the absence of a strategic plan. The typical narrative seems to be that if someone has mental health challenges, they should see a therapist. However, based on the results we achieve in a relatively short timeframe, I believe this approach may not suit everyone.
A more effective strategy should involve a plan to uncover the root causes of individuals' challenges, giving them hope that therapy is not a permanent fixture in their lives. The focus should be on resolving issues rather than merely managing symptoms.
While further therapy might be necessary as clients confront various layers of trauma, the current model often feels like an endless cycle.
At Heal, we maintain that unresolved life experiences are metaphorically stored in the solar plexus energy center, creating low-grade stress that can lead to various physical, mental, and emotional health challenges.
Photo by Tim Goedhart on Unsplash
The first step we take is to help clients release these blockages through progressive journaling and targeted, action-oriented talk therapy. We also incorporate techniques like breathwork, nervous system regulation, gratitude exercises, and fostering a growth mindset. Once the issues are identified and addressed, we focus on releasing them through acceptance, transformational breathwork, guided meditation, and even NLP when necessary.
We do not endorse a model of repetitive discussions about problems without a resolution. Instead, we encourage clients to view these experiences as anchors that prevent them from moving forward.
While every individual is unique—some clients find value in their therapy sessions—many who have experienced trauma or face challenges such as low self-esteem and chronic procrastination often find traditional therapy counterproductive.
Section 1.2: A New Perspective on Mental Health
Although my views may seem controversial, I am not alone in this perspective. An increasing number of traditional therapists are shifting towards more action-based methodologies, moving away from mainstream medical conventions.
The pharmaceutical industry operates like a subscription model, and the same could be said for traditional therapy. This system thrives on ongoing client relationships, benefitting shareholders while often neglecting the need for a cure.
While my observations may come off as harsh, I assure you that every client who has completed our tailored programs has undergone what could be termed a full recovery. They often emerge as transformed individuals, equipped with ongoing strategies to manage life's challenges.
Our action-based talk therapy and coaching programs are designed to be completed within 6–12 weeks, and to date, we have not seen any client relapses. We remain available for support long after clients finish their courses, providing a safety net as needed.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of any approach can only be assessed through results.
What are your thoughts? Have you experienced therapy? Do you take antidepressants or other long-term medications? What has your journey been like? I would love to hear your insights.
For additional information about our services, please feel free to contact us through the links below to arrange a complimentary, no-obligation conversation.
You don’t have to endure in silence or accept a life of perpetual struggle.
What is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?
This video provides an overview of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and how it can be an effective treatment for various mental health issues.