Radio Buttons — (7 Practical Scenarios)

1. Use radio buttons when it’s essential for users to see all available options before making a selection.

2. When the default choice does not hint at the other available options.

3. When users need to compare choices, as it's easier to do so when options are visible side by side.

   This example illustrates radio buttons for comparison, showcasing only two options, while drop-downs present over 15 choices.

4. When there are fewer than five options available.

5. When it enables users to skim through choices more easily.

6. To allow users to achieve their goal with just one click.

7. When there are more than five options, but space is available for display.

   This suggests that if you have space for fewer than 15 options, using radio buttons is typically a better choice for user experience.

When to Choose Drop-Down Menus — (7 Scenarios)

1. When you want to present users with a default optimal choice.

   Here, the US dollar is the default since the user is in the US. The rule of 15 options also applies here, but you get the idea.

2. When you have between five and 15 options and lack space to display all of them.

3. When there are more than 15 options.

4. In situations where the default option will satisfy most users.

5. When alternative choices may confuse or mislead inexperienced users.

6. When viewing the selected item is more crucial than seeing the other available choices.

7. When the correct option exists in your database, and you just need the user to confirm it.

   It’s common to see pre-selected options for language, address, phone number, etc.

Conclusion

Exercise caution when implementing drop-down menus, as:

• They can slow users down; they must first access the drop-down and then select an option to submit, moving the target away from the user.
• Users might overlook options and forget to change the default setting.
• Accidental clicks outside the box can close the drop-down, forcing users to start over.

Despite requiring multiple clicks, the examples provided show that drop-downs can enhance usability in various scenarios.

It's vital to understand your users and product before making interface decisions. Even with radio buttons, if there is a default option, ensure it is the most suitable for the context.

Many designers opt for the first option as the default, while some forms have no selections at all; however, the Nielsen Norman Group advises against leaving options unselected.

While this article cannot cover every possibility, we can gradually build a resource to enhance user experience.

That’s all for today! Remember, we can start with best practices, but sometimes we may discover they don’t fit a particular product or user base, and that’s perfectly fine. As I always say, learn the rules so you can break them with intent.

Thank you for reading! I look forward to seeing you in the next article.

If you found these tips helpful, consider subscribing to receive updates via email whenever I post new content.

?? Follow me for the latest updates ? Support my work by buying me a coffee ?? If you enjoyed the article, give it a clap!

If you found this article useful, please show your appreciation!

Looking forward to our next discussion!

Medium is an excellent platform for UX designers to expand their knowledge and stay informed. Consider signing up for a membership at $5 a month for unlimited access to content, including works by Ilma. If you register through this link, Ilma will earn a small commission, which helps support her efforts.