Understanding Optimization: A Comprehensive Overview of Its Importance
Written on
Optimization is a crucial aspect of decision-making and problem-solving that aims to identify the most effective solution from a set of alternatives. This article provides an introduction to optimization, illustrating its principles and applications through relatable examples.
In this article, we will explore the following key areas: - Definition of optimization - Importance of optimization - Applications of optimization - Differences between constrained and unconstrained optimization - Core components of an optimization model - Simple examples of optimization problems
Note that we will not delve into complex mathematical methods or optimization software.
What is Optimization?
At its core, optimization involves selecting the best possible solution from various options. However, what constitutes "best" can differ based on the specific problem at hand. For instance, "best" could refer to maximizing profit, minimizing costs, saving time, or reducing resource usage. Therefore, the definition of "best" is contingent on the context of the issue you are addressing.
Optimization becomes necessary when multiple solutions exist for a problem.
Why is Optimization Important?
Understanding the significance of optimization is essential. To grasp its relevance, we can refer to the four levels of analytics, as illustrated by the Gartner Analytic Ascendancy Model. This model depicts the progression from simpler forms of analysis to more complex ones, where foresight represents the highest level of complexity.
- Descriptive Analytics: This level provides insight into historical data, such as average website visit duration or annual sales growth.
- Diagnostic Analytics: This level addresses the question of why certain outcomes occurred, often by examining underlying data for potential causes.
- Predictive Analytics: At this level, we forecast future events using machine learning models, which rely on optimization techniques to deliver accurate predictions.
- Prescriptive Analytics: This is where optimization itself comes into play, guiding decisions on how to achieve desired outcomes, such as optimizing retail shelf space or logistics for shipping.
The insights derived from optimization contribute significantly to efficiency and competitive advantage, making it a powerful tool for strategic, operational, and tactical decision-making.
Where is Optimization Used?
Optimization is more prevalent in everyday life than one might realize. For instance, GPS applications like Google Maps utilize optimization algorithms to determine the shortest routes to destinations.
Optimization has practical applications across various industries. Below are two notable examples:
Example 1: UPS
A prominent case of optimization in transportation is UPS's initiative to enhance delivery efficiency. The company aimed to minimize delivery times and fuel consumption by avoiding left turns, which can cause delays. To achieve this, UPS developed a proprietary software known as ORION to optimize delivery routes.
The chart above compares a standard delivery route with the optimized route from ORION, demonstrating a 30-mile reduction in distance. Since its implementation, ORION has saved UPS approximately 100 million miles and 10 million gallons of fuel annually.
Example 2: US Army
Another classic example of optimization dates back to World War II when the US Army sought to minimize food costs while ensuring soldiers met their nutritional needs. Economist George Stigler determined an optimal diet comprised of specific food items, balancing cost and nutrition.
The optimal diet identified by Stigler, while not necessarily appetizing, was cost-effective, amounting to just $39.93 per year at the time (approximately $831 today).
Unconstrained vs. Constrained Optimization
In graphical terms, optimization involves locating maximum or minimum points within a given context.
The graph illustrates unconstrained optimization, where the highest peak represents the maximum and the lowest valley signifies the minimum. In practical scenarios, however, constraints exist due to limited resources, altering the optimization landscape.
Here, constraints shift the maximum point downwards, demonstrating constrained optimization, which is typically encountered in real-world optimization problems.
Three Core Elements of an Optimization Problem
An optimization problem generally consists of three fundamental components, which we can illustrate using the Stigler diet example:
- Objective Function
- Decision Variables
- Constraints
Objective Function
The objective function is crucial as it helps define what "best" means in the context of the problem. In the diet scenario, minimizing annual cost was the goal.
Decision Variables
Decision variables are the factors that can be controlled or adjusted. In Stigler's case, these included the types of food and their quantities.
Constraints
Constraints are the limitations on decision-making. Stigler's problem included several nutritional requirements that had to be satisfied.
Solution
In discussing solutions, we refer to:
- Solution: A specific set of values for each decision variable.
- Feasible Solution: A solution that meets all constraints.
- Optimal Solution: The best feasible solution, providing the highest value.
Optimization Problem 1
Let's explore a simple optimization problem to reinforce our understanding. The context involves a company, "It's So Fluffy LLC," aiming to maximize profits through the sale of two products: cuddly unicorn pillows and plump cat dolls.
The company has limits on production, with a maximum of 2 unicorn pillows and 3 cat dolls available. The profit per product is $15 for the unicorn and $10 for the cat.
Identifying the three core components of this optimization problem:
- Objective Function: Maximize profit.
- Decision Variables: The quantities of unicorn pillows and cat dolls produced.
- Constraints: Maximum production limits based on available materials.
Now, visualizing the problem on a graph, we can illustrate the constraints and feasible solution space.
From the feasible solutions, the optimal profit is achieved by producing 2 unicorn pillows and 3 cat dolls, yielding a total profit of $60.
Optimal solution: fluffy unicorn = 2, plump cat = 3.
Optimization Problem 2
Building upon the first problem, we introduce an additional constraint: the company can produce a maximum of 4 products per day.
This new constraint affects the feasible solution space, which we can visualize on the graph.
In this adjusted scenario, the optimal profit is now $50, achieved by producing 2 unicorn pillows and 2 cat dolls.
Optimal solution: fluffy unicorn = 2, plump cat = 2.
Problem 1 vs. Problem 2
Comparing the solutions of the two problems reveals that the additional constraint in Problem 2 resulted in a smaller feasible solution space and a lower profit.
What Happened?
The introduction of a new constraint reduced the options available, emphasizing the importance of carefully evaluating constraints during the optimization setup. Relaxing constraints can often yield better solutions.
Thank you for reading, and we hope you enjoyed this exploration of optimization.