The Unrealistic Future of Sci-Fi: Why Reality Prevails
Written on
Chapter 1: Encountering Science Fiction
My first exposure to science fiction came when I was nearly twelve, after leaving Africa for a damp period in Britain. During this time, the UK was transitioning from black-and-white television to color, and due to a shortage of local programming, it eagerly acquired rights to showcase American shows. Star Trek, with its vibrant characters and broad appeal to audiences aged ten to forty, was a standout choice. This is where I discovered pointy ears, the starship Enterprise, and the bewildering inconsistencies that permeate the sci-fi genre.
I struggled to comprehend how advanced technology could facilitate faster-than-light travel across vast distances, yet appeared to remain underutilized in many facets of the Star Trek universe. The idea that people could be instantly transported from one location to another raised questions about the slow processing capabilities of the ship's computer when answering the captain's queries. How could such a sophisticated vessel still bear the resemblance of a 20th-century naval ship? Why were the devices used by the crew so cumbersome, despite evident advancements in miniaturization that should have allowed for powerful computing and energy generation in compact forms?
If this advanced technology truly existed, why were humans still being transported when unmanned missions would clearly be safer, cheaper, and less prone to errors?
I grasped that the concept of relativity was often overlooked to facilitate storylines, though I lacked the knowledge of quantum mechanics at that age to realize that the transporter technology was fundamentally flawed. Even with these narrative necessities, Star Trek seemed nonsensical to me.
As I explored more American programming, I realized that sci-fi often mirrors classic Westerns—space cowboys, if you will. The horses became starships, the Indians morphed into hostile aliens, and the rugged leather attire was replaced by futuristic clothing. Yet, this transformation barely scratched the surface. Aside from a few notable exceptions like Arthur C. Clarke and Ray Bradbury, many sci-fi writers seem to recycle old tales with a thin layer of futuristic sheen.
By my mid-teens, I recognized that the true value of effective sci-fi lies in reflecting contemporary issues, allowing us to view them from a slightly different perspective.
Section 1.1: Sci-Fi's Disconnect from Reality
In essence, sci-fi often lacks real scientific grounding and original storytelling. The problem lies in the disjointed nature of the gadgets and technologies showcased, lacking an understanding of how real-world advancements happen in tandem. This is why we utilize lithium-ion batteries for our cellphones instead of steam power. In many sci-fi narratives, the elements simply do not align. Captain Kirk can traverse the cosmos in a sophisticated spacecraft, yet he must manually adjust the dial on his outdated communicator, and his messages still require relay through his secretary.
Ultimately, sci-fi is often as tedious as clichéd romance novels or simplistic action flicks, failing to grasp the complexities of real life. Everything is simplified to fit a basic plot, which leads to a widespread misunderstanding of reality.
Section 1.2: The Impact of Misconceptions
Unfortunately, humans are easily swayed and often lack the ability to discern the significant gap between fantasy and intricate reality. We accept what we see on screen as truth. Today, countless individuals believe that DNA can precisely identify a unique person among millions, even though it cannot achieve this reliably. Many assume that being shot will invariably cause a person to fall, while in reality, unless conditioned to believe otherwise, individuals can remain standing despite being shot. The misconceptions extend to numerous beliefs about defibrillators, memory, and many other concepts that are distorted by cinematic portrayals.
The influence of sci-fi on public perception is profound, leading many to conclude that "humanity's future lies in space!" However, the truth is that our future, however brief it may be, is firmly anchored on Earth. Both physics and economics present formidable barriers to the prospect of traveling to even our closest stellar neighbors. Robotic missions controlled by AI can accomplish far more efficiently and at a fraction of the cost compared to human endeavors.
Chapter 2: The Illusion of Space Travel
The first video, "Reclaiming Our Sci-Fi Future | James Pethokoukis | Ep. 44," discusses the misconceptions around sci-fi narratives and their impact on public perception of technology and space exploration.
In reality, we have evolved beyond outdated methods of communication and transportation. We no longer rely on steam engines or telegrams; instead, we utilize multifunctional devices like smartphones that consolidate various technologies.
In contrast, the simplistic worlds often depicted in sci-fi fail to connect these advancements. Writers frequently lack a grasp of the interconnectedness of modern technologies, leading to a skewed portrayal of future possibilities.
As a result, the widespread belief that humans will eventually leave Earth en masse is misleading. Sci-fi's portrayal of space travel as straightforward and safe lulls us into complacency, preventing recognition of the vast gulf between fiction and reality.
We squander immense resources on missions that yield little value, ignoring essential scientific research that could yield significant benefits. Characters like Captain Kirk may entertain, but they also contribute to a misunderstanding of scientific realities among the general populace.
In summary, it is time to acknowledge the fictional nature of characters like Captain Kirk and the worlds they inhabit. We cannot hope to turn these fantasies into reality any more than we could engage Sherlock Holmes to resolve historical mysteries.
It's high time we matured in our understanding and allocated our resources more wisely.
ADDENDUM
For those interested in the practical aspects of space exploration, consider exploring the following articles:
- Musk’s Mars Madness: Why humans will never colonize the solar system
- We Shall Never Travel To The Stars: How physics defeats fantasy in the real world
- Why We Will Never, Ever, Mine The Asteroid Belt: Sci-Fi is a totally unreliable guide to reality
- Space Travel: Fiction Versus Reality: Why humans won’t explore the stars, or even our own solar system
- Why There Are No Space-Faring Civilizations: And why there never will be
- Why There Will Be No Mars Colony: Unpacking the fantasy behind space colonization